• Choke Creek

    Overall Rating: ★ Rating:94 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.7★ Rating:94 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.7★ Rating:94 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.7★ Rating:94 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.7½ Rating:94 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.794%
    Choke Creek
    Lauren Small
    Bridle Pass Press, 2008
    Fiction/Historical Fiction
    ISBN: 0615220118
    299 pages

    Synopsis

    Set in the vivid, clear light of the West, Choke Creek tells the story of two families who trace their roots to the Indian Wars. Fifteen-year-old Evie Glauber is descended from the newspaperman who reported on the famous Battle of Choke Creek, while Eason Swale, the boy she loves, is the great-grandson of a cavalryman who fought in it. Eason enlists in the Army and goes to Vietnam, but when he comes back a deserter, everything Evie believes in is thrown into question—including the truth about what really happened on the banks of Choke Creek.

    Critique

    It’s not often that I get the pleasure of reading a book that written like a tapestry or a beautiful painting. Most of the books for teens and tweens nowadays are written to be non-stop action page-turning thrillers that will sell like hotcakes. I’m not saying I don’t enjoy them, at least at some level, but I can only drink smoothies for so many meals before I want a full five-course meal.

    Unfortunately, it’s often difficult to find books that have a bit more muscle to them because they’re only picked up by smaller publishing companies that don’t have the big marketing budgets to sell a million copies. Thus, I’m really pleased that Lauren Small reached out to me to review her book because I thoroughly enjoyed every word of it.

    Evie and Eason feel like real people dealing with difficult circumstances and decisions that effect their past and their present. Small has done a magnificent job of weaving historical elements into the text, wars past and present, and showing the reader what sorts of comparisons exist in a “history always repeats itself” sort of way. It’s a poignant novel in many ways, especially considering that we continue to be warmongers, feeling like our slaughter of people all over the world is justified because they think differently than we do, or they threaten our way of life.

    The language is beautiful, poetic, and although it’s the kind of writing that takes a long time to get through, it’s the kind of writing that a reader ought to languish, like watching Casablanca vs. reality TV. I recommend this text to readers 14+.

    Rating Rubric

    Enjoyable Read: ★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5100%
    Original Story: ★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5100%
    Original Plot: ★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4☆ Rating:80 Fraction:480%
    Language: ★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5100%
    Asthetics: ★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5100%
    Depth In Characters: ★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5100%
    Depth In Story: ★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5100%
    Social Commentary: ★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5★ Rating:100 Fullstar:5 Star Piece:0 Fraction:5100%
    Layers/Complexity: ★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4☆ Rating:80 Fraction:480%
    Classroom Text: ★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4★ Rating:80 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0 Fraction:4☆ Rating:80 Fraction:480%
    Overall Rating: ★ Rating:94 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.7★ Rating:94 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.7★ Rating:94 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.7★ Rating:94 Fullstar:4 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.7½ Rating:94 Star Piece:0.7 Fraction:4.794%

    For the Classroom

    Even though the subject matter is a fictionalized account of real events, this book would be a perfect classroom companion for studies regarding the Vietnam War or the massacres of Native American peoples throughout the US, especially in the Colorado area.

    Other Books You May Like


    No Responses to “Choke Creek”

    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.